Quote:
Originally Posted by hanninadina
Przemek was it who cancelled every one of my statements.
|
I don't remember myself removing your posts recently.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by hanninadina
I was wondering too, a 64 cm male got P 1. But, I am in breeing for Briards - Berger de Brie - french herdings dogs for 10 years. And there it is possible and no fault, if a female or male dog is 1 cm less or more in hight as the standard says, if everything else is without faults.
|
I especially took a look at Briards standard and it is more strict than that of CzW. It's openly written that going below minimum is disqulification. In CzW standard there is no such sentence. It's just some people's interpretation - stop people overinterpret the stanrdard and don't say things that are not included in it. Going below minimum is a fault - TRUE. Going below minimum is disqualification - THAT IS OVER-INTERPRETING. No such sentence exists in the breed standard. Just that it is a fault since the standard says it's below minimum. If you want it to be strict change the standard. An example from Briards standard: "
Code:
SIZE: 0,62 m to 0,68 m for males.
0.56 m to 0,64 m for females.
The length of the body must be more important than the height at shoulders. The general appearance of the Briard is rangy.
Penalization: Cobby dog : no Excellent. Sizes superior to 0,68 m and 0,64 m.
Disqualification: Below the minimum. More than 2 cm above the maximum size.
Nice and clear but... this is a quote from Briard standard.